Wednesday, April 3, 2013

Redos and Retakes

One of the seminal moments in my life as an educator occurred about fifteen years ago when my school’s administration required teachers to practice mastery teaching with an emphasis on allowing redos and retakes.

Of course, the teacher’s lounge was abuzz with questions and critiques of the new policy. Redos and retakes took the brunt of the criticism.

Today, I’m an unabashed believer in retakes and redos; my “answers” to the more common criticisms follow.

Over the years, I’ve become more comfortable with redos and retakes thanks to my own experiences, my colleagues, and, in particular, the writings of Rick Wormeli and Ken O’Connor.

Complaint 1: Students need to be held accountable
I agree, students must be held accountable for learning.  So which policy holds students to a higher standard? One in which we allow students to fail or skim by with a D or one in which we use redos and retakes to ensure student mastery?

Students need multiple chances to grow and learn. Each teacher’s goal should be for ALL students to master the essential learnings.

The research of Carol Dweck shows that if we teach students that their intelligence can increase, they will do better in school. In her ground breaking book Mindset, Dweck speaks of the benefits of a growth mindset, meaning that people believe that they can improve their abilities by dedication and hard work. As teachers, we must ensure students view failure as part of the natural learning process and an opportunity to improve. The long-term consequences of one’s mindset impact the entirety of a person’s life. As teachers, we play an important role in instilling a growth mindset in each of our students. We must teach our students to rise to the challenge of our high expectations, to continuously learn, and we must reward them for their sustained efforts.

Requiring students to master their learning through redos and retakes until they meet your high expectations demands far more of the students than letting them accept a failing grade.

Complaint 2: Students will take advantage of retakes by not doing their best the first time.
Honestly, this was one of my greatest concerns when I first began allowing redos and retakes. I was soon assuaged that it wasn’t a problem. Because the redo/retake required an additional commitment (time and effort), students never banked on getting to redo it. 

Complaint 3: This isn’t how the real world works.
Really?

Last time I checked, you’re allowed to take driver’s test, SATs, ACTs, GREs, Bar Exams, and MCATs multiple times. Honestly, it sounds pretty pompous and petty for any teacher to say, my quiz on Chapter 6 is more important than any of the aforementioned tests.

Could you imagine how many people wouldn’t have their driver’s licenses if it was one and done? Confessional: I wouldn’t—parallel parking got me the first time.

When you enter your doctor’s office, does the diploma and certification on his/her wall distinguish whether it took him/her 1, 2, or 3 times to pass the MCATs? Of course, not.

I’ve since left the classroom and have entered administration. I wish I could say that every teacher has met every deadline, but I can’t. For a variety of reasons—some good and some bad—deadlines are missed all the time. And this is not unique to academia.

Need other examples?
  • The publishers who suggest corrections and modifications before the author resubmits his work reject authors.
  • Bosses would ask to see/hear a presentation before the young businessperson presents it to clients. 
  • The apprentice plumber who works side-by-side with a master plumber who continually provides corrective feedback.

When it comes down to it, pretty much every “real world” job allows for redos and retakes. The investment capital makes it impossible to fire an employee for one failure. We must invest in our students by reteaching and retesting whenever they don’t meet our standards.


Complaint 4: They won’t have the opportunity to redo work next year in….
They won’t have time to redo work in college.

Let’s dissect this bit-by-bit. First, I don’t think it’s a true statement. Although I haven’t stepped foot on a college campus in two decades, please allow me to share one of my own experiences. One of my most challenging college classes was US History, Part 1.  Everyday, upon entering the class, we were greeted with a five-question multiple-choice quiz. If we scored below a 4/5, we were required to write an essay covering the chapter(s) covered by the quiz. Students were assigned either a passing or failing grade for each chapter. The professor’s message to me was clear: each student bears the responsibility for his/her learning. Nothing less than a 4/5 is acceptable. Not only did this instill in me grit and responsibility, I also learned the material.

As a ninth grade World History teacher, when students entered my class on the first day of the year, I wanted students who were proficient in world geography (the 8th grade social studies class). I could care less, if it took the student one day or the entire year to master the geography curriculum.  

Our high school recently held a roundtable in which we invited recent graduates to return and speak to students and teachers. A teacher posed the question about redos and retakes to the college students. Unanimously, the students voiced their approval of redos and retakes. One high-achieving student stated, “[The teachers who allowed redos and retakes] set a high bar; one that challenged us to do our best.”

Another student chimed in, “I felt better prepared for college because I had to master it [the content].”

These students experienced firsthand the value of redos and retakes. Through practice, re-teaching, feedback and retakes, these students mastered the learning and developed a growth mindset. To be adequately prepared for their next year, whether it’s 1st grade or college, students need to know the content and the skills.

Complaint 5: It’s not fair to the students who do well the first time.
The ability to retest should not be limited to low-achieving students. High-achieving students benefit from retests and retakes. When a high-achieving student scored a B on a test, he/she was often the first to sign-up for a retake.

Side note: Knowing that they have the opportunity to redo/retake a quiz or test, I’m willing to bet that the high-achievers will be less likely to cheat because they know they have a second chance.

Anecdotally, only rarely did I have any of my high-achievers complain about my retest policy—No, it wasn’t because they didn’t voice their concerns to me. I heard plenty of complaints about my projects, my lectures, my expectations, etc.  Those who did complain most likely were used to an educational system that distinguished between the elite and non-elite.

Conclusion
We must move away from the I taught it; I tested it; Most of the students got it philosophy. Instead we must ask ourselves, “When students don’t get it, what do we do?”

We must answer, “We reteach and re-assess.”

Sources
Dweck, Carol S. Mindset. London: Robinson, 2012. Print.

O'Connor, Ken. How to Grade for Learning: Linking Grades to Standards. Arlington Heights, IL: SkyLight Professional Development, 2002. Print.

Wormeli, Rick. Fair Isn't Always Equal: Assessing & Grading in the Differentiated Classroom. Portland, Me.: Stenhouse, 2006. Print.




42 comments:

Anonymous said...

Reed, you totally nailed it. Right on all counts.

Sarah Whisenhunt said...

This was a refreshing analysis. However, as a fellow Virginia public schools educator, how do you confront/combat the climate of SOL/EOC tests? I am a non EOC test teacher, but I see my students every testing session stress the possibility of not being able to expedite. True, they do get a retake in the form of retaking the class, but they are so focused on getting that verified credit and the passing score. Also, students who make the proficient score can't retake to get advanced.

What I'm trying to convey is how to you get our SOL/EOC/ABCD/FGHJ students to buy in to mastering those standards and not on the actual test score they receive?

Reed Gillespie said...

Thanks for reading and commenting.

Your questions are ones that every SOL teacher struggles with. How do you ensure true and meaningful student learning and not just SOL success? I think each teacher needs to balance the unique needs of his/her students to determine how they approach this.

My personal opinion is that this is less of a redo/retake issue, and more of how do you approach your teaching. For some students, passing the SOL is meaningless, but for others passing the SOL test might represent a great accomplishment. Each student is different. My job as a teacher is to ensure that each student is appropriately challenged and has an opportunity to learn and grow throughout the year. While some might believe that SOLs are a measure of teacher effectiveness (the tests can't/shouldn't be ignored), we must look beyond them and keep our focus on learning and growth.

Hope this answered your questions.


Tim Bedley said...

I've been REQUIRING my elementary students to redo inadequate assignments for about 20 years. Teachers need to get into their kids' heads in order to be effective. What do kids value most? The majority favor having their assignments in the past more than they favor good grades. So the motivation is built in to do quality work if they know that they will have to redo it until they get it right. Most elementary students these days will gladly take a low grade just to know the assignment is done and over with. The focus needs to be on learning, not on completion.

Reed Gillespie said...

Great points Tim. By doing as you suggest your instilling a growth mindset in your students, which is a true life lesson and one that will forever make a difference in your students' lives.

Ryan Reed said...

Just saw this post on Twitter and decided to put some thoughts on my own blog here: http://historycustomized.blogspot.com/2014/02/playing-school.html

Unknown said...

This is so wonderful - I am going to send it to all the principals with whom I work. You explained this so powerfully. This piece will be a tremendous resource.
One quick question: I had trouble understanding this sentence:
"The publishers who suggest corrections and modifications before the author resubmits his work reject authors."
Can you help me out? thank you!

Unknown said...

Great article, thanks. A practical question: did you change the tests for the students who were retaking it, or did you let them retake the same test? Thanks!

webspace said...

We are Webspace Inc. organization working as the Best Digital Marketing Company in USA and we give many services to our client that is website designing.
Web Development company in Los Angeles
web design New York
web development New York
online marketing New York
ecommerce web development New York
internet marketing New York
SEO company New York
seo company USA
Web development company
Web development company California
Web development company Los angeles
Professional Web Design Services USA
Website Design Comapny
Web Design Company
webiste design services
website design company in usa
web development company
website development comapny in usa
webdevelopment company usa
Web Development Company in USA
Web Development Services in USA
website development company in usa
web development company
webisite development company

Midnight Partner said...

Best and Top Interior Designers in Gurgaon If you are confounded? Try not to stress. We offer a free conference to help you in settling on a choice with the best vision and quality that you merit.
Best Interior Designers In Gurgaon
Best Interior Designers In Delhi
interiors designing company in gurgaon
interior design company in gurgaon
interior designer in gurgaon
interior designers in gurgaon
interiors designing company in delhi
interior design company in delhi
interior designer in delhi
interior designers in delhi
interior designer delhi
top interior designers in gurgaon
interiors company in gurgaon
top interior decorators in gurgaon
interior designers and decorators in gurgaon
modular office furniture in gurgaon
modular kitchen manufacturers in gurgaon
office furniture in gurgaon
home furniture manufacturer in gurgaon
wooden modular almirah manufacturer in gurgaon
wooden partition manufacturers in gurgaon
false ceiling manufacturer in gurgaon
greed false ceiling manufacturer in gurgaon

Midnight Partner said...

Spaces Interiors prime spotlight is on giving the prevalent assistance of inside planning. The structuring for any sort of room can make an air or make an impression of their way of life.
||Best Modular Office Furniture in Gurgaon
||modular furniture manufacturerin gurgaon
||office furniture manufacturer in gurgaon
||office chair manufacturer in gurgaon
||modular furniture manufacturer in delhi
||office furniture manufacturer in delhi
||modular kitchens in gurgaon
||modular kitchen in delhi
||designer kitchens in gurgaon
||kitchen interior in gurgaon
||luxury kitchens in gurgaon
||Best Office Furniture In Gurgaon & Delhi
||office furniture in gurgaon
||office furniture in delhi
||school furniture in gurgaon
||office furniture services in delhi
||Best Home Furniture Manufacturer in Gurgaon & Delhi
||home furniture in delhi
||home furniture in gurgaon
||living room furniture in gurgaon
||bedroom furniture in gurgaon
||living room furniture in delhi

robbyjaksan said...

http://www.baldingcelebrities.com/2011/07/us-presidents.html
http://freebie-licious.blogspot.com/2015/07/must-have-monday-with-kinder-alphabet_20.html
http://www.allthatshewantsblog.com/2018/09/fair.html
https://cloud.googleblog.com/2013/01/auto-manufacturers-take-new-turn-with.html
http://www.alittlekiran.co.uk/p/blog-page.html
https://therubberpunkin.blogspot.com/2010/01/to-make-this-little-goodie.html
http://www.pocketlover.se/2013/12/dystopispecial-de-lux.html
http://reedgillespie.blogspot.com/2013/04/redos-and-retakes.html

robbyjaksan said...

At AOL Mail Login Help you will get master and solid tech answers for all your AOL mail questions and issues.
||AOL Support Toll Free Number
||aol technical support contact number
||aol technical support phone number
||aol email technical support number
||aol technical support number
||aol email tech support number
||aol customer support number
||aol support phone number
||aol toll free number
||AOL Desktop Gold Download Support Number
||aol gold download technical support phone number
||aol gold download email technical support number
||aol gold download technical support number
||aol gold download email tech support number
||aol gold download customer support number
||aol gold download support phone number
||aol gold download toll free number
||AOL Desktop Gold Support Number
||aol gold technical support contact number
||aol gold technical support phone number
||aol gold email technical support number
||aol gold technical support number
||aol gold email tech support number
||aol gold customer support number
||aol gold support phone number
||aol gold toll free number

christianhunter01 said...

||www.office.com/setup
||Enter Product Key - Setup Office
||www.office.com/setup
||www.office.com/setup enter product key
||office.com/setup
||office setup
||office com setup
||ms office setup
||www office com setup
||office.com/ setup
||www.office.com/ setup
||office.com/myaccount
||www.office.com/myaccount

shown Harper said...

||D-link Router Support Phone Number
||d-link router support phone number
||d-link router support
||d-link router tech support
||d-link router tech support phone number
||d-link router customer service number
||d-link router tech support usa
||d-link router tech support canada
||d-link router help
||d-link router telephone support number
||d-link help desk for router
||go to d-link router support
||d-link router 24x7 technical support number
||d-link router live chat technical support
||d-link router phone number tech support
||d-link router technical support usa
||d-link router help support canada






shown Harper said...



||Arris Router Support Phone Number
||arris router support phone number
||arris router support
||arris router tech support
||arris router tech support phone number
||arris router customer service number
||arris router tech support usa
||arris router tech support canada
||arris router help
||arris router telephone support number
||arris help desk for router
||go to arris router support
||arris 24x7 technical support number
||arris live chat technical support
||arris phone number tech support
||arris router technical support usa
||arris router help support canada



christianhunter01 said...

||Office.com/myaccount
||office.com/setup
||Office My Account
||office.com/myaccount
||www.office.com/setup
||office.com/setup
||office setup
||www.office.com/setup

Trees R Us said...

Trees R Us Tasmania is Hobart’s trusted Tree Removal experts. We offer total tree services in Hobart and surrounding suburbs, taking care of your existing garden. Trees R Us are dedicated to providing you with a superior quality tree service, Residential, Commercial, Real Estate Agents & Insurance Companies.

The team at Trees R Us Tasmania have over 35 years of experience in tree services throughout Hobart and the surrounding suburbs.

If you need emergency tree service in the Hobart Region, including the surrounding suburbs, contact Trees R Us Tasmania today. We offer 24 HRS- 7 Days a week service and free on-site quotes for all our tree services, including tree removal, stump and root removal, stump grinding, and mulch sales

tree removal services commercial area hobart
tree felling hobart
tree professinals hobart
tree trimming hobart
tree removal hobart
professional services tree felling hobart
quality pruning hobart
safe tree removal services hobart
tree felling specialists hobart

Bed Pari Bangalore Escorts said...

Are you looking for Escorts Bangalore or some fun with our Female high profile escort service in Bangalore.

Bangalore escorts service
Independent Bangalore escorts
Bangalore Escorts
Escorts Bangalore
VIP Escorts Bangalore
Escorts in Bangalore
Escorts in Bangalore
Escort in Bangalore
Bangalore escort
Independent Bangalore escorts
Independent Escorts in Bangalore
escort service in Bangalore
Bangalore Russian Escorts
Escort Agency in Bangalore
Call Girls in Bangalore
Bangalore Call Girl
Bangalore Escort Girls
Bangalore Escorts Agency
Bangalore Escort Girls

Deepika Rai said...

Get the best Bangalore Escorts & sexy call girls at Deepika Rai, the best escorts service provider in Bangalore, contact us to get erotic massage service, sex service. Get your dream girl today.

Bangalore Escorts
Independent Bangalore Escorts
Escorts Service in Bangalore
Bangalore escorts services
Bangalore Escorts
Independent Bangalore Escorts
Bangalore Escorts Services
Escorts Services in Bangalore
Bangalore Escorts
Independent Bangalore Escorts

Nikitha Bangalore Escorts said...

High Class Girls Bangalore Escorts
Best escorts agency Bangalore
Young and Sexy Call Girls in bangalore
Curvy Escorts
Bangalore Escorts
Independent Call Girls
Escort Girl in Bangalore
Independent Model Escorts
Best Escorts Agency
VIP Bangalore Escorts

Nikitha Bangalore Escorts said...

Bangalore Escorts
Independent Bangalore Escorts
Independent Bangalore Escorts

Bangalore Escorts
Bangalore Escorts
Bangalore Escorts
Bangalore Escorts
Independent Bangalore Escorts

Garmin GPS said...

GPS users in flawlessly using their garmin devices.Free Garmin Map Update in your Garmin device. These free updates from Garmin’s side are to enhance user experience. Hence, you should have free map updates on your device. Regular Garmin express updates help you to avoid traffic rush, long routes and save plenty of traveling time. You can enjoy a smooth ride every time if you have latest map in your Garmin Device.

Garmin Nuvi said...

You can view all the available maps that are present in your Garmin Nuvi series on your computer. Garmin Nuvi is a great application where you can view available routes for your upcoming destination. Not this, you can mark the important waypoints like gas stations, restaurants, etc. Once you are done with planning, transfer all data to your Garmin GPS device. latest available updates, downloading and installing Garmin Nuvi Update. Garmin Nuvi Update Garmin Map Update

Sonam Sharma said...


Thanks For sharing this useful info welcome to Vasant KunjEscorts
I am Sonam, a recently single married horny who is looking For a safe and sane man to meet to satisfy my needs.Our services are open 24 hours With a friendly smile and a Seductive body with curves, 100% genuine.
Call Girls in Vasant Kunj
Vasant Kunj Escorts

Ishika Sharma said...

By and by you're beginning to see Romantic Enchantment in the world with Delhi Call Girls. Various men who need to date a lady, simply do not understand where to fulfil Escorts. While Delhi Call Girls are attractive, certain, and productive notwithstanding all that they're going to just with huge exertion find ravishing Escorts in Delhi up to this point.

Norton Setup said...

Digital Marketing Company
Best Digital Marketing Company
SEO Services
PPC Services
SEO Services Company
SMO Services
SMO Services Company

Unknown said...

Perdisco myob help at Myperdiscohelp.com is currently available 24/7 round the clock to assist and aid students with accounting in a very interactive way by making them understand the core
concepts. Perdisco myob provides guidance and help in a very cheap and affordable rate, with discounts and weekly offer coupons and 30% off for the first time users.

SmithRed said...


Help For Assignment

Are you searching for assignment help? Best assignment expert is now assisting students with the best Homework
Help For Assignment at a low and affordable price with many offers.

Promote Abhi - Business Chalega Tabhi/Startup Development Company said...

https://www.reddit.com/user/govermentj0bs/comments/otrai6/government_jobs_in_india_better_career_improved/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3
Independant Call Girls in Delhi
Brother Printer Troubleshooting
Icloud SMTP Server Setup
Avast Antivirus Help
Delhi Escort Services
Government Jobs in Indiahttps://www.reddit.com/user/govermentj0bs/comments/otrai6/government_jobs_in_india_better_career_improved/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3
Independant Call Girls in Delhi
Brother Printer Troubleshooting
Icloud SMTP Server Setup
Avast Antivirus Help
Delhi Escort Services
Government Jobs in India

Chain Of Responsibility Training And Management Plans Victoria, NSW said...

The aim of chain of responsibility (COR) is to make sure everyone in the supply chain shares responsibility for ensuring breaches of the HVNL do not occur. Under COR laws, if you are named as a party in the chain of responsibility and you exercise (or have the capability of exercising) control or influence over any transport task, you have a responsibility to ensure the HVNL is complied with.
JMH Training & Compliance can develop and implement a Safety Management System specific to your organisation to ensure compliance with the HVNL and Work Health & Safety Act and train key personnel to be competent in maintaining that system.

Chain of responsibility

Unknown said...

Do you need an urgent loan of any kind? Loans to liquidate debts or need to loan to improve your business have you been rejected by any other banks and financial institutions? Do you need a loan or a mortgage? This is the place to look, we are here to solve all your financial problems. We borrow money for the public. Need financial help with a bad credit in need of money. To pay for a commercial investment at a reasonable rate of 3%, let me use this method to inform you that we are providing reliable and helpful assistance and we will be ready to lend you. Contact us today by email: daveloganloanfirm@gmail.com Call/Text: +1(501)800-0690 And whatsapp: +1 (501) 214‑1395

NEED A LOAN?
Ask Me.

Kundli Jyotish said...

Great post! you explore this topic in a very effective way I want to appreciate your work, thank you for sharing such useful information!!

horoscope today
talk to astrologe
kundli jyotish

horoscope today

Happiness said...

This blog has enlightened me on what I suppose to know about the school that I wish to apply for, as a matter of fact, it has shown me the necessary steps I should take. Here, you can see funai cut off mark for accounting

Kundli Jyotish said...

This is a really great post and thanks for sharing this useful information with us.


matrimonial

Amazon Product Review Blog said...

you explore this topic in a very effective way I want to appreciate your work, thank you for sharing such useful information!!

Good Health And Good Skin
OnePlus 9 5G
Glowing Skin
Body Scrub

zarkazijar said...

This is an incredible posting! I found enormous joy reading it, am bookmarking this for your new post. coe-agbor cut off mark for economics

priya sahani said...

Es𝚌orts Service Adilabad

c𝚊ll G𝚒rl Kharghar

Mumbai Es𝚌orts

Ernakulam c𝚊ll G𝚒rl Service

c𝚊ll G𝚒rl in Bakhtiarpur

c𝚊ll G𝚒rls in Bikaner

Es𝚌ort Tadepalligudem

james smith said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
james smith said...

Our Do My Assignment for me service is mainly designed for students to provide guaranteed success in achieving great marks in their assignments.

Help for you said...

Excellent writing has been produced by you. Since I write material, I am aware of how much research is required to create high-quality content. I am sure that your work meets the standards of the many companies that provide pay someone to write my assignment . Kudos to you. I'm grateful you shared this.

Anjana Kuntal said...

You can Watch Online Hindi channels in Qatar by subscribing to a suitable service that offers Indian channels. Several providers offer a range of Hindi content, including movies, TV shows, and live events. Check out your options and choose the one that meets your preferences.